It’s Monday, I’m Nithya Sudhir. I collect words, chase patterns, and write about whatever makes me curious.
What happens when you don’t sell on Black Friday?
A Swiss bag brand found out six years ago. Here’s what it learned.
On Black Friday 2021, a Swiss bag maker announced 100% off everything.
Nothing was for sale, though.
FREITAG, a Zurich brand that turns used truck tarpaulins into one-off bags, closed its online store and instead sent every visitor to S.W.A.P. (Shopping Without Any Payment), where they could trade a FREITAG they no longer used.
Every other brand was cutting prices, FREITAG took the price away altogether.
Black Friday is two weeks out, and your offers are probably live already. However, a brand that refused to sell still has a few lessons worth borrowing.
🤝 This edition is kindly brought to you by Levanta
Black Friday trained your customers to wait for 40% off. Sitewide discounts cost you margin on customers you’d already won.
Creators introduce your product to audiences that never saw it, and you pay commission only when a sale lands.
Levanta handles influencer and affiliate recruiting, attribution, and automated payouts across Shopify, Amazon, Walmart, and more, with commission rates you control.
REVO, a skincare-device brand, drove $1M+ in Amazon sales within months through creators. 96% came from first-time buyers, versus 28% on average for Amazon ads.
The 100% Off sale with nothing to buy
FREITAG has never run a Black Friday sale. According to head of communications Elisabeth Isenegger, the brand doesn’t run holiday promotions at all. Since 2019, it has given shoppers something else to do on the day instead.
Graphic designers Markus and Daniel Freitag founded the brand in Zurich in 1993. They needed a waterproof bag for cycling, so they cut one from a used truck tarp.
Today the brand makes around 400,000 one-off bags and accessories a year and sells them through 30 stores and more than 300 retail partners.
FREITAG thinks and acts in cycles. It offers repairs, customization and a free bag exchange to keep every bag in use for longer.
Closed for shopping. Open for something else.
Every year since 2019, FREITAG has found a new way to keep shoppers away from the checkout.
2019. Launched S.W.A.P., a year-round, Tinder-style platform where FREITAG owners swap bags with each other.
2020 to 2022. Closed the online store for the day and sent every visitor to S.W.A.P.
2023. Stopped selling in its stores for 24 hours and lent bags for free for two weeks.
2024. Closed every checkout and turned 20 stores into swap events.
Shoppers who already own a bag can still want a change. They don’t need something new, just something different. S.W.A.P. gives them that without a sale.
What it changed?
Skipping the sale paid off in two ways.
A community, not a queue. In its first year, S.W.A.P. drew nearly 6,000 users, who uploaded 4,450 bags and swapped 1,046, according to Wiener Bezirksblatt.
Coverage instead of discounts. Each campaign earned press from design and trade titles, including Creative Review, Glossy and FashionUnited.
RÆBURN, MUD Jeans, flamingos life and Brompton have joined FREITAG’s No Black Friday initiative, each with an alternative of its own.
Why does a brand that refuses to sell get this much attention?
What does "Don't Buy" make us think?
“Don’t buy” grabs attention because it breaks the script shoppers expect on Black Friday. Four reactions follow.
1. “Wait, that’s not how Black Friday works.”
Every BFCM email promises a bigger discount, so “don’t buy” stands out. According to Heckler and Childers (1992), a message that breaks expectations, called schema incongruity, gets processed more deeply. Shoppers also remember it better, as long as the surprise stays relevant to the message.
2. “Why are they telling me this?”
Shoppers read every marketing message for its motive, according to the persuasion knowledge model. So “don’t buy” gets decoded too. It can read as care for the product, a stand on values, or just a louder way to get noticed.
3. “Do they actually mean it?”
The brand’s track record decides. In two studies, Catherine Armstrong Soule and Brandon Reich (2015) found that shoppers judge a “buy less” message by how well it fits the brand’s existing sustainable image. The same “don’t buy” can read as altruistic from one brand and exploitative from another.
4. “Honestly, they have a point.”
A quarter of shoppers globally avoided Black Friday and Cyber Monday on purpose, according to Kantar. Among those who did shop, 42% regret a purchase. A brand that says “don’t buy” puts words to a feeling many shoppers already have.
So should marketers stop selling on Black Friday?
Not necessarily. Closing the checkout suits brands whose whole model already backs it up, like FREITAG. For every other brand, the useful lesson is smaller: Give shoppers something to do besides buy.
A brand relationship includes everything that happens between purchases. On a day when a quarter of shoppers stay away on purpose, that space matters more than the discount.
Brands can run the sale and still help customers get more from what they already own. Two brands have already shown how:
Buy back what shoppers already own. During Black Friday week in 2020, IKEA ran BuyBack Friday in 27 countries and paid customers in store vouchers for furniture they no longer needed. Shoppers requested 482,000 quotes that week, and IKEA handed out EUR 2.1 million in vouchers, according to Insight DIY. Every voucher went back into an IKEA store.
Reward repair right next to the deal. Fairphone ran its Black Friday 2025 promotions on new phones, with a free case and screen protector, and added repair offers for existing owners. The goal was to get owners choosing repair over replace.
What are you doing this Black Friday?
Hit reply and let us know!
How's the depth of today's edition?
See you tomorrow,
Nithya
P.S. If you want to get a case study about your own brand, reply to this email. If you’d like to reach our newsletter audience (founders, creators, and marketers), click the button below.
If you’re new here, I’m over the moon you’ve joined us! To help me craft content that’s actually useful (and not just noise in your inbox), I’d love it if you took 1 minute to answer this quick survey below. Your insights help shape everything I write.
Insane Media is more than one voice
💡 Dive into our other newsletters - where psychology meets the founders, creator economy, Human resources and AI trends.









