It’s Tuesday, I’m Nithya Sudhir. I collect words, chase patterns, and write about whatever makes me curious.
The goodbye nobody plans for
Every subscription has an end date. Most brands never see it coming.
Pet food is different. It runs on a schedule, and the customer it serves has a lifespan.
In June 2022, Anna Brose posted about her dog Gus. After he died, she contacted Chewy about returning an unopened bag of his food. Chewy refunded her in full, told her to donate the food to a shelter, and sent flowers with a note signed by the person she'd spoken to.
Her post passed 740,000 likes. Thousands of pet owners replied with their own Chewy stories.
Some of those stories included something stranger: a hand-painted portrait of the pet that had just died.
That's a lot of effort for a customer who has just told you they no longer need your product.
Then you look at where Chewy's money comes from.
In the quarter ending August 2, 2026, customers on Autoship, Chewy's repeat-delivery program, accounted for 84.6% of net sales. That's $2.82 billion out of $3.33 billion.
When almost all of your revenue is recurring, the cancellation becomes one of the most important moments in the relationship.
So today, we're looking at why that goodbye matters so much, and what it does inside a grieving customer's head.
🤝 This edition is kindly brought to you by Omnisend
The usual loop is export the PNG, rename it, upload it, swap it into the email, then do it all again after the next round of feedback. Omnisend’s Canva integration cuts that down to saving the design in one Canva folder. It syncs to your Image Library every 12 hours, or instantly with Sync now, and the latest version is waiting under Select file in the email builder.
Switching platforms before BFCM? Omnisend migrates your setup in 5 days, free.
The moment Chewy designed for
Most retention playbooks are built to stop a cancellation. Chewy's shows what happens when a brand treats one as a chance to show up.
Based on customer stories reported by Business Insider and Fortune, the pattern looks like this:
The customer cancels, or asks to return food, because their pet has died.
Chewy refunds the order and suggests donating the food to a shelter.
Flowers and a handwritten note arrive, signed by the person they spoke with.
Some customers also receive a hand-painted portrait of their pet.
The portraits run at real scale. In 2020, the AP reported that Chewy was sending more than 1,000 free paintings a week to select customers. One artist told them he painted 20 to 50 a week.
In 2023, Insider reported that Chewy accidentally copied 177 of its portrait artists on a single email about a new contract.
The word "select" matters here. Portraits go to some customers, and they also mark birthdays, holidays and other milestones along with memorials.
Why the goodbye works
1. Grief that nobody else acknowledges
When a loss isn't socially recognized, any recognition lands harder.
In a 2023 Pew survey, 97% of US pet owners said their pets are part of the family, and 51% said they're as much a part of it as a human member.
Yet pet loss rarely comes with bereavement leave or a card. Grief researcher Kenneth Doka called this disenfranchised grief in 1989: a loss that can't be openly acknowledged or socially supported.
So when flowers arrive from the company that delivered the dog's food, it might be the only condolence the owner gets.
2. The ending writes the memory
We judge experiences by their most intense moment and how they end, more than by how long they lasted.
In a 1993 study, Daniel Kahneman and colleagues had people hold a hand in 14°C water for 60 seconds. In a second trial, they added 30 more seconds as the water warmed slightly to 15°C.
A significant majority chose to repeat the longer trial. More pain, better ending. It's called the peak-end rule.
Years of on-time Chewy deliveries blur together. The peak and the end land in the same week: the pet dies and the customer cancels.
If that week ends with a refund and flowers, that's the Chewy they remember.
3. Unexpected gifts create a debt
We feel pulled to give back when someone gives to us, especially when it feels personal and unplanned.
In a 2002 restaurant study, leaving a chocolate with the bill lifted tips from 15.1% to 17.8%. The biggest tips came when the server seemed to spontaneously offer an extra piece, which the researchers put down to reciprocity.
Chewy's gesture is unexpected, personal and asks for nothing. A grieving customer can't return it yet, but many will soon: in a 2019 Wamiz survey, 49% of UK pet owners said they get another dog or cat within six months of a loss.
When they shop for that new pet, they know which brand showed up for them.
4. Making it right only goes so far
Fixing a problem raises satisfaction. It doesn't reliably bring people back.
A pet dying has nothing to do with the brand. The cancellation that follows still puts the customer where a service failure would: sad, out of pocket, and talking to your support team.
A 2007 meta-analysis by Celso de Matos, Jorge Henrique and Carlos Rossi looked at the service recovery paradox, the idea that a well-handled problem can leave customers happier than no problem at all.
They found good recovery boosted satisfaction, but had no significant effect on repurchase intentions or word of mouth.
The refund is the recovery. It makes the customer whole.
The flowers and the portrait go past whole, and that extra step is what people photograph and share. Anna Brose's post reached hundreds of thousands of people.
The line between care and a sales tactic
Some viral videos describe this as Chewy exploiting grief.
What keeps it from feeling that way is what's missing from the box. There's no ask attached.
Marketing researchers Marian Friestad and Peter Wright described this in their 1994 persuasion knowledge model. Once people recognize a persuasion attempt, they start evaluating and resisting it.
A condolence note with a "20% off your next pet" code becomes a sales message the moment it's read. The gift stops being a gift.
The reciprocity only works while the customer believes the kindness is real.
How DTC brands can use this
You don't need a team of portrait artists. You need a plan for the moments when customers leave for reasons that have nothing to do with you.
1. Add life events to your cancellation flow.
Offer reasons like "my pet passed away" or "my baby outgrew this," and route those to a person instead of a retention offer.
2. Refund the last order before they ask.
When the reason is a loss, tell them to keep or donate what's already shipped.
3. Give your support team a budget and permission.
Chewy's notes come signed by the rep the customer actually spoke to. That detail is what makes it personal.
4. Keep every offer out of the gesture.
No discount codes, no "come back" links, no survey. Send the kindness on its own.
5. Measure it over the long window.
Track how many life-event cancellations come back within 6 to 12 months, and compare them with your other churned customers.
The bottom line
Every subscription ends. Most brands only plan for the start.
Chewy plans for the last box, because the last chapter of a relationship is the one people retell.
Your customers will remember how you handled the moment they no longer needed you.
Make it worth remembering.
How's the depth of today's edition?
As always, hit reply if something in here hits home.
See you tomorrow,
Nithya
P.S. If you want to get a case study about your own brand, reply to this email. If you’d like to reach our newsletter audience (founders, creators, and marketers), click the button below.
If you’re new here, I’m over the moon you’ve joined us! To help me craft content that’s actually useful (and not just noise in your inbox), I’d love it if you took 1 minute to answer this quick survey below. Your insights help shape everything I write.
Insane Media is more than one voice
💡 Dive into our other newsletters - where psychology meets the founders, creator economy, Human resources and AI trends.
