It’s Tuesday, I’m Nithya Sudhir. I collect words, chase patterns, and write about whatever makes me curious.
In 2005, marketing professors Keith Coulter of Clark University and Robin Coulter of the University of Connecticut ran a simple test.
They showed shoppers ads with a regular price and a sale price.
Some ads printed the sale price in a smaller font than the regular price. The rest printed it larger. The prices never changed.
When the sale price was printed smaller, shoppers perceived it as significantly lower, rated the deal as better value and were more likely to buy, according to the study.
Same offer. Same number. Smaller print, more sales.
Clearly, shoppers don’t only read prices, they measure them.
🤝 This edition is kindly brought to you by Insense
There’s still time to get UGC for Q4; find your creator personas in seconds, UGC in 14 days.
There's still time to get fresh creator content live for Cyber Week and December - from your creator personas.
Insense gets you fresh UGC in 14 days or less: post one brief, vetted creators apply within hours, and each one can send 20+ raw clips to cut into new hooks and angles. You pay only when you approve the content, with lifetime usage rights on every clip.
Book a free strategy call by December 4th and get $200 towards your first campaign.
Same number, different print
BFCM planning usually stops at the offer. 20% off or $15 off? Buy one, get one? A free shipping threshold? Teams debate those for weeks.
Far fewer ask how big the sale price should look on the website.
They should. The font size of the discounted price swung sales by 28%, according to Peter Steidl in his book Neurobranding.
That goes against every design instinct.
A big sale seems to deserve a big, bold number that grabs attention. But the brain reads a big number as a big price.
The Coulters’ 2005 paper, “Size Does Matter,” published in the Journal of Consumer Psychology, found that anything linking “small” or “low” to the sale price made it feel cheaper. Shoppers judged the same sale price as lower when the ad simply described the product as “low friction.”

Image Source: Conjointly
What shapes a sale price?
Size, order and even punctuation change how a sale price feels.
Size, in particular, works in two directions, and each sells a different kind of pleasure, according to a 2016 study by Praveen Aggarwal and Rajiv Vaidyanathan. The two pleasures come from economist Richard Thaler’s theory of mental accounting.
Acquisition utility is the value of the product compared with what it costs, while transaction utility is the thrill of the deal itself, measured against the price the shopper expected to pay.
To put it simply,
A big regular price triggers transaction utility. It makes shoppers think “Look how much I’m saving.”
A big sale price triggers acquisition utility. It makes them think “Look what I’m getting for this.”
What else changes our perception?
What comes first. Shoppers anchor on the first number they see, according to Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky. Next to a high original price, the sale price looks small.
The difference. A $50 bag marked down to $48 looks like it isn’t worth it. But a $50 bag marked down to $10 looks like something’s wrong with it. A big sale price draws the eye to the price itself, so shoppers spend less time comparing it with the original, according to a 2023 study.
Length and a comma. People judge “$1,522” pricier than “$1522”. Adding the cents makes a price feel nearly 9% bigger in a 2012 study by Keith Coulter, Pilsik Choi and Kent Monroe, according to strategy+business. A longer number takes longer to say in our heads, and the brain reads that as more money.
Why small feels cheap to our brain?
Our brain takes shortcuts when it judges numbers.
It uses one ruler.
Our brain doesn't keep a separate measuring tape for size, distance, time and amount. Neuroscientist Vincent Walsh called this A Theory of Magnitude. Because of that, "big" leaks from one kind of size into another. So, a number printed in a big font feels like a big number. A number printed small feels like a small one.It matches things.
When two clues agree, the brain reads them faster and trusts them more. A sale price is already the lower number. Print it smaller too, and its size and its value tell the same story. Print it bigger, and the clues clash, and the brain stumbles, according to Keith and Robin Coulter. Psychologists call this the size congruity effect.
None of this is a conscious choice. Keith Coulter and Patricia Norberg traced these effects to the brain's automatic, unconscious sense of relative size. That means, shoppers don't decide that a small font means a small price. They just feel it before they think about it, which is why the trick likely works even on people who know about it.
Your BFCM pricing checklist
Shrink the sale price first. Then test these four changes before BFCM.
Spread the prices apart: Leave visible space between the original price and the sale price. Across four experiments, Coulter and Norberg found that a wider horizontal gap between prices made the discount feel bigger. Shoppers also rated the deal as better value and were more likely to buy.
Put the original price on the left. People picture numbers on a line running from small on the left to large on the right. Psychologists call this the SNARC effect. With the original price on the left, shoppers estimated a higher reference price because the product seemed higher quality, according to a 2025 study. The product looks better as well as cheaper.
Watch the right digits: When the left digits match, keep the right digits small. An item on sale for $211 from $222 looks like a better deal than one on sale for $188 from $199, according to the Coulters. Both discounts are $11. Shoppers compare the right digits, and 1 against 2 feels like a bigger gap than 8 against 9.
Drop the symbol where it’s safe. Test removing the currency symbol from banners and product cards, and keep it at checkout. In a Cornell study, diners at an upscale casual restaurant spent an average of $5.55 more, about 8%, when the menu had no dollar signs. Co-author Sheryl Kimes says references to dollars remind people of “the pain of paying.”
I’m assuming that most brands will spend this week tweaking the discount. But before adding another 5% off, shrink the sale price, space the prices apart and test both. It costs nothing. Who knows it might work better than a bigger discount.
How's the depth of today's edition?
Have you tested your price display yet? Hit reply.
See you soon,
Nithya
P.S. If you want to get a case study about your own brand, reply to this email. If you’d like to reach our newsletter audience (founders, creators, and marketers), click the button below.
If you’re new here, I’m over the moon you’ve joined us! To help me craft content that’s actually useful (and not just noise in your inbox), I’d love it if you took 1 minute to answer this quick survey below. Your insights help shape everything I write.
Insane Media is more than one voice
💡 Dive into our other newsletters - where psychology meets the founders, creator economy, Human resources and AI trends.








