It’s Tuesday, I’m Nithya Sudhir. I collect words, chase patterns, and write about whatever makes me curious.
Can a freebie prove expensive?
In 2012, one free song made an iPod package worth $65 less.
Black Friday bundles have a habit.
They keep growing.
A tote here. A sample there. A free gift badge on top.
Every addition feels generous, and shoppers are there for it!
In fact, free gifts ranked among the three most appealing promotions, according to Deloitte's holiday survey.
But research has also found that one wrong addition to an offer can make it look less worthy, making customers question it altogether.
It's Monday. Let's get into it.
🤝 This edition is kindly brought to you by Stripo
Black Friday is Nov 27, and inboxes fill up fast. Give shoppers something to play with: put the discount under a scratch card they reveal right in the email. In Stripo it's a ready module, no code needed, and you keep sending from the ESP you already use.
Getting started is quick. Forward last year's Black Friday email to your Stripo import address, and it becomes an editable template.
New to Stripo? AD-TO-CART readers get 2 months of Stripo Medium free (monthly plan) with code ADTOCART until November 30.
More can look like less
It's the age of the iPod. Everyone has earphones in, and everywhere you go, people are listening to music.
You decide to buy one for yourself.
At the store, you find two options.
An iPod Touch with a cover.
The same iPod and cover, plus one free song.
Which one would you feel is worth more?
The second one, right?
In an experiment, psychologists Kimberlee Weaver, Stephen Garcia and Norbert Schwarz split participants into two groups—sellers and shoppers—to find that out.
Sellers were asked to sell an iPod with a cover. They could then choose whether to add a free song to it or not. 92% of them did.
The Shoppers saw each one of the two packages and were asked how much they would pay for it.
Shoppers who saw the plain package said $242 on average. Those who saw the package with the free song said $177.
One free song knocked about $65 off the whole package.
The sellers thought they were adding value, while the shoppers saw less.
Why sellers and buyers judge the same package differently
Sellers count the items. Buyers average them.
According to the research, the brain processes a bundle or offer in two ways.
Adding. Each positive item raises the judgment. Sellers lean this way because they assemble the offer piece by piece.
Averaging. Shoppers take in the whole offer. A single song beside an iPod drags the overall impression down.
Researchers call this gap the presenter's paradox.
Here's what actually happens as a shopper looks at an offer.
They start with a question. According to Meyvis and Janiszewski, shoppers test a simple hypothesis. Will this product give me what I want?
They sort every detail into two piles. Each piece of information either confirms the answer is yes, or it doesn't. The researchers found that irrelevant details land in the "doesn't confirm" pile alongside negative ones. The dilution effect shows that when weak or irrelevant information sits beside strong information, the strong information loses some of its pull.
The weak extra lands in the wrong pile. A free song proves nothing about the iPod, so it counts as "not confirming". The more of those a shopper sees, the weaker their belief in the offer becomes. Even a relevant extra can dilute the offer if it doesn't prove the main benefit.
Unsure shoppers look for reasons. According to Simonson, Carmon and O'Curry, when shoppers are uncertain about what a product is worth or what they prefer, they look for reasons to justify their choice. An extra they don't value becomes a reason against buying, and an easy thing to criticize.
Freebies that earn their price
A freebie lifts the offer when it adds to the experience without competing with the hero.
Three ships: Freebies as a finish line
Founded by Connie Lo and Laura Thompson in 2017, Three Ships is a Toronto skincare brand selling natural, affordable products.
Instead of one big gift, Three Ships turns its cart into a ladder of small, useful freebies.
Stack freebies in the cart. Shoppers unlock free shipping at $49.99, free samples at $65 and a travel pouch at $85.
Show the gift after the decision. The rewards appear in the cart, away from the product page where shoppers judge the product itself.
Make the freebie fit the routine. Samples and a travel pouch help shoppers use and carry what they bought. Here, relevance adds value because every gift serves the same benefit as the hero.
Sassy scents: The freebie is the product
Sassy Scents, formerly Sassy Wax, is a Bristol wax melt brand that Keely Parsons started from her very own kitchen.
Sassy’s gifting is clean and clever:
Every order gets a freebie. Customers receive two free wax melts worth £7, according to Parsons.
The freebie sells the range. Parsons says the gift lets people try more of the brand's wide variety of scents.
It feeds conversion. Parsons says the promotion improves conversion. The freebie is more of the product shoppers came for, in a scent they haven't tried yet, which gives them a reason to come back.
When did you last say no to something free?
Audit your offer before adding another bonus
Each extra earns its place by strengthening the overall impression.
Rank every component. Name the hero. Mark each add-on as strong, medium or mild beside it.
Question the mild ones. A trial sachet next to a €200 jacket competes for the same impression.
Test with and without. Split traffic between the full offer and the offer minus the mild extra. Compare conversion, AOV and margin alongside clicks.
Let shoppers choose the gift. A 2024 Journal of Retailing study found that a choice of free gifts raised perceived value and purchase intentions compared with one fixed gift. Choice also softened the drag of a lower-value gift.
Before adding another gift to this Black Friday’s bundle, brands can test whether customers value the complete offer more with it or without it.
How's the depth of today's edition?
We've learned to believe more is better, but now we know that the brain can read a longer list of perks as a weaker deal.
So, how would you make that difference this BFCM?
Let me know! Hit reply!
Until next time,
Nithya
P.S. If you want to get a case study about your own brand, reply to this email. If you’d like to reach our newsletter audience (founders, creators, and marketers), click the button below.
If you’re new here, I’m over the moon you’ve joined us! To help me craft content that’s actually useful (and not just noise in your inbox), I’d love it if you took 1 minute to answer this quick survey below. Your insights help shape everything I write.
Insane Media is more than one voice
💡 Dive into our other newsletters - where psychology meets the founders, creator economy, Human resources and AI trends.
