It’s Monday, I’m Nithya Sudhir. I collect words, chase patterns, and write about whatever makes me curious.
What Happens When DTC Goes Retail?
DTC was supposed to kill retail. Instead, it is reinventing it.
Glossier is shutting 9 of its 12 locations. Allbirds, the brand sold one million pairs in two years, closed all 60 of its US stores and sold its assets for $39 million. In 2024, Outdoor Voices shuttered all 15 of its retail locations. Parachute closed 19 of its 26 stores. The DTC class of 2017 to 2021 lost over $60 billion in cumulative valuation.
And yet, 58% of shoppers say they would be more likely to buy from a DTC brand if it had a physical store. Physical retail still accounts for 80% of global sales. Sephora and Ulta logged 25 and 23 new brand debuts respectively in Q1 2026 alone, most of them DTC-born.
Brands move into retail. Many collapse. But customers want that—or do they?
Today, we’re finding out why DTC goes retail and what happens when it does.
It's Monday. Let's get into it.
🤝 This edition is kindly brought to you by Peec AI
When someone asks ChatGPT for the best product in your category, does yours come up, or a competitor's?
AI builds the shortlist before shoppers ever reach your site, and your analytics can't see it. Peec AI asked 12 ecommerce and SEO experts how to win those AI recommendations and turned it into a four-move playbook you can run this quarter.
We partner with a select group of brands that we use or admire, allowing this newsletter to remain free and independent. Reach out for your campaign here.
What Happened in the 2010s?
For most of the 2010s, the DTC model ran on three things: cheap Facebook ads, patient venture capital, and the novelty of buying direct.
Global venture capital funding hit $643 billion in 2021, up from $60 billion in 2012, as zero interest rates made everyone a venture capitalist for the DTC space.
Then suddenly, between 2021 and 2023, all three disappeared.
And when interest rates rose in 2022, venture capital investment in DTC startups collapsed, falling 97% from its $5 billion peak in 2021 to just $130 million by 2023.
The engine stopped.
So, brands went looking for other ways to reach customers, and most of them ended up in retail.
The Wholesale Solution
Why give that up?
Because the shopper who walks past the product in Sephora or Target, picks it up, and buys it costs the DTC brand nothing in media spend.
That makes the 20% margin make sense, right?
The main goal is not to choose between DTC and retail. But to treat each channel as doing a different job: DTC for storytelling, data, and margin. Amazon for search capture. Sephora or Ulta for discovery and cultural credibility. Wholesale for reach and replenishment.
DTC is now a must-have for brand building and customer ownership. But wholesale remains a core profit and reach driver.
If it’s really that good, why do some brands still choose to stay DTC-first?
Every purchase tells the brand exactly who bought, what they bought, and when they came back. In wholesale, that data belongs to the retailer.
DTC brands own the story, the packaging moment, the email that follows, the experience from first click to delivery. On a retail shelf, their story gets compressed into a label and a price point.
For brands built on a specific community and a specific feeling, wholesale distribution can dilute the very thing that made customers loyal in the first place.
And mainly, because going mainstream means risking the people who cared first. That fear turns out to be well-founded.
Aisle See Myself Out
For customers who found the brand before everyone else, their beloved DTC-brand going retail can feel like a personal loss.
Here’s the science.
1. Psychological Ownership: they feel like something was taken from them.
Research by Pierce, Kostova and Dirks established that people develop genuine feelings of ownership over things they do not legally own.
Three pathways create this: control, intimate knowledge, and self-investment.
Early DTC customers walked all three: they found the brand, recommended it to friends, and built part of their identity around it.
When Glossier announced its Sephora partnership in 2023, the community that had built the brand on Reddit and Instagram mourned. The reaction was grief at the loss of something that had felt like theirs.
2. Optimal Distinctiveness: they feel like the club just let everyone in.
Marilynn Brewer's Optimal Distinctiveness Theory shows that people simultaneously need to belong to a group and feel distinct from the mainstream.
With DTC brands in their early phase you are part of a community of people who know, and that community is exclusive enough to mean something.
When consumption gains symbolic meaning as a marker of group membership, mass availability destroys that meaning even when the product itself is unchanged.
Stanley cups are the clearest example. The tumbler went from niche outdoor community to Target endcap and TikTok hysteria in under eighteen months. Sales exploded. The original community, outdoor workers, hiking enthusiasts, quietly left.
3. Identity Signal Erosion: they stop being able to say anything about themselves by carrying it.
Research on identity-based consumer abandonment showed that when a product becomes associated with an undesired group, the original group abandons it specifically to avoid being misread.
Away luggage built its identity around the design-conscious urban professional who travelled differently. By 2019, Away bags were ubiquitous in every airport terminal in the world. The brand that made you feel like a specific kind of traveller started making you look like everyone else in the queue.
4. Psychological Contract Breach: they feel like the brand broke a promise it never officially made.
A 2025 study published in ScienceDirect on consumer reactions to brand transgressions found two distinct mechanisms: withdrawal triggered by functional failures, and indignation triggered by ethical ones.
For values-led DTC brands, going retail is sometimes the second type.
Reformation built a fierce community around limited availability and ethical production. When it expanded aggressively into wholesale, customers questioned whether the sustainability claims could hold at scale. The implicit contract, that Reformation was small and honest because it chose to be, felt broken the moment it stopped being small.
What Smart Brands Keep in Mind Before Going Retail
Go from strength, not desperation. Retail exposes weakness, it does not fix it. Allbirds had 60 stores. The stores did not save it. If customers aren't already looking for your product, a shelf won't change that. Here’s a good read on: How The Best Breakout DTC Brands Prepared for the Jump to Walmart and Target.
Keep something exclusive online. Omni-channel shoppers deliver a 30% higher lifetime return on investment than single-channel shoppers — but only when each environment feels intentional and distinct.
Design the store as a brand embassy, not a shelf. The DTC-born brands winning in Sephora and Ulta in 2026 are using the retail environment to tell a story, sampling experiences, visual identity, and brand theater.
Move slowly. Outdoor Voices opened 15 stores and closed them all. Casper went from pop-ups to 60 stores and was taken private at a 75% discount. Mejuri took eight years to reach 50 locations. Its omnichannel customers now yield 2.5 times higher lifetime value than online-only customers.
If you’re a DTC brand staring down a retail pitch deck, the real question isn’t “Should we go into stores?”
It’s: What does this channel need to do that my website can’t, and what do I refuse to give up in exchange?
If you can answer that clearly, in a spreadsheet and in your customer’s brain, going retail doesn’t have to be the end of your story. It can be the sequel.
How's the depth of today's edition?
As always, hit reply if something in here hits home.
See you next week,
Nithya
P.S. If you want to get a case study about your own brand, reply to this email. If you’d like to reach our newsletter audience (founders, creators, and marketers), click the button below.
If you’re new here, I’m over the moon you’ve joined us! To help me craft content that’s actually useful (and not just noise in your inbox), I’d love it if you took 1 minute to answer this quick survey below. Your insights help shape everything I write.
Insane Media is more than one voice
💡 Dive into our other newsletters - where psychology meets the founders, creator economy, Human resources and AI trends.
