Hi, I’m Nithya Sudhir. I collect words, chase patterns, and write about whatever makes me curious.
It’s Monday.
Someone forwarded this? 💌Subscribe to get it fresh, every Tuesday.
Missed an issue? 💬Catch up on past essays.
Curious what else we’re building? 💡Insane Media lives here.
Want your campaign in front of our users? 📌Reach out here.
Looking to join the convo? 📲Follow along on Instagram.
The Transparency Trigger — What Love and Loyalty Demand from Brands
Last week, Cracker Barrel learned the hard way that loyalty can’t be redesigned.
Here’s the backstory: In August, the company unveiled a new logo, dropping its iconic man-in-overalls-and-barrel for a cleaner, modern mark.
It backfired spectacularly.
Within days, the change became a culture-war lightning rod, even drawing a jab from the White House. The stock fell 16 percent. Foot traffic tumbled.
All that over a logo.
It made me think: what’s the real cost of love and loyalty? Can’t a brand change anymore?
It’s Monday! Let’s get into it.
The Real Price of Loyalty
Of course it can, but only if its telling the truth.
Turns out, the cost of love is honesty. And the cost of loyalty is transparency.
Transparency is an emotional currency in marketing.
It’s proof that a brand is willing to be seen.
And it pays: 87 percent of shoppers say they’ll pay more for products from brands they trust. Nearly 50% even admit that they would stop buying from a brand if they felt the brand was inauthentic.
So what exactly happens in our brains when brands tell the truth?
The Fairness Effect
When people are treated fairly, their brains react as though they’ve just won.
Neuroscientists Golnaz Tabibnia et al. (2008) found that fair interactions activate the ventral striatum, the same reward center triggered by money — or chocolate.
Fairness literally feels like pleasure.
When brands act transparently, they give customers that same neural payoff: a small dopamine rush of being respected.
Moral Identity Signalling
Purchasing isn’t just consumption, it’s self-communication.
Mazar & Zhong (2010) showed that consumers who make ethical purchases experience a rise in moral self-regard, a phenomenon they call moral licensing.
Essentially, when we buy good, we feel good. Transparency lets customers turn values into visible choices. Each purchase becomes a quiet declaration: “I’m thoughtful. I care.”
Signal Theory
In markets riddled with information asymmetry, voluntary openness is a power move.
Economist Michael Spence (1973) proved that revealing costly or sensitive information signals confidence and quality.
So, when a brand says, “Here’s how it’s made, here’s what it costs,” it communicates strength through risk. Openness itself becomes the competitive moat.
Everlane: How Radical Transparency Became a Business Model
When Everlane launched in 2011, the apparel market was already crowded — Zara and H&M were winning on speed, J.Crew on aesthetics and luxury brands on status. Everlane entered with none of that — but with one big idea: “Radical Transparency.”
“We believe our customers have the right to know how much their clothes cost to make.”
Within the first year, Everlane built a 60,000-person waitlist for its first $15 “Luxury Tee.”
2012 revenue reportedly reached $1.1 million, and by 2015 it was $35 million.
Their CAC (customer acquisition cost) was near-zero in early years because earned media and word-of-mouth drove growth — people shared Everlane’s transparency posts as social proof of their own ethics.
Between 2014–2018, Everlane’s transparency became its brand equity.
During the 2018 “Choose What You Pay” campaign — where customers literally picked their own price tiers (reflecting true costs) — Everlane saw a 260% increase in conversions compared to standard sale events.
Transparency turned a basics label into a cultural statement.
By 2020, the halo had dimmed slightly, but its legacy stayed:
It re-taught consumers to expect openness from DTC fashion.
It built a $250 million-plus valuation on a single moral principle.
And it proved that clarity can out-perform hype.
💡Transparent Takeaways
1. Show, don’t say. Proof is a stronger ad than perfection.
2. Turn values into action. Help your customers signal who they are.
3. Be confidently visible. The brands that reveal more, risk less.
However, people can tell when something’s all sparkle and has no substance. A majority of consumers believe that brands today prioritize maintaining a positive image over delivering real value to consumers.
This is why it's more than important than ever for brands to be honest with their people.
Because when love and loyalty depend on transparency, the real question every brand has to ask themselves is — what price can we pay for love?
How's the depth of today's edition?
As always, hit reply if something in here hits home.
See you next week,
Nithya
P.S. If you want to get a case study about your own brand, reply to this email. If you’d like to reach our newsletter audience (founders, creators, and marketers), click the button below.
If you’re new here, I’m over the moon you’ve joined us! To help me craft content that’s actually useful (and not just noise in your inbox), I’d love it if you took 1 minute to answer this quick survey below. Your insights help shape everything I write.
Insane Media is more than one voice
💡 Dive into our other newsletters - where psychology meets the founders, creator economy, Human resources and AI trends.
